
This article is part of the thematic channel The Carbon Observer: subscribe to the newsletter
Final negotiations on Article 6 are underway at COP31, prior to any draft decision text (or rather, a set of drafts) going to the next stage – the plenary – or to the ministers, should irreconcilable positions persist after the first round. But what was being negotiated this year?
Firstly, it is worth recalling that at COP29 in Baku two years ago, the rulebook for Article 6 was finalised, with provisions on registries, the associated Sustainable Development Mechanism, appeal options for local communities, and much more. In effect, the infrastructure for the new UN carbon credit market had been finalised, while, on one side, some countries had already begun signing bilateral agreements under Article 6.2, and others were watching with interest the development of the centralised mechanism (the successor to the old Kyoto Clean Development Mechanism) under Article 6.4, the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (PACM). In these final days of the COP in Antalya, negotiations are taking place on both, but no longer on the rules – or not only. What matters now are the projects, and to keep the mechanism alive, resources are needed that do not seem to be forthcoming.
In a context of a growing number of countries entering into bilateral cooperation agreements under Article 6.2 – extending well beyond the historical pioneers (Singapore, Switzerland, Japan) – the COP needed to conduct an initial review of the bilateral system, resulting in fairly substantive discussions and exchanges even before its commencement. What should be done now with this initial review to ensure that the lessons learnt do not fall on deaf ears – or, rather, get lost in the background noise of these massive negotiations? Delegates appear inclined to draft a text – a decision – designed to “encourage” countries to act in line with best practices and lessons learnt. But which ones? As ever, the debate shifts from technical to political, particularly given how small the sample of projects launched to date actually is. Therefore, it is highly likely that this working group will conclude by simply “taking note” of the process.
A recurring theme in the debate has been the possible application of rules and safeguards structured under the centralised mechanism (Article 6.4, the PACM) to bilateral agreements under Article 6.2 as well, which is an idea that appears to appeal to the European Commission, preparing to launch its Facility for the purchase of carbon credits for the period 2036–2040 in February 2027. To date, however, some countries have discussed this possibility in the plenary without, in any instance, asking the COP to take a decision on the matter – after all, the rules for doing so already exist.
A number of countries, mainly in Africa and Latin America (those with the most extensive forests), have instead called on the COP to ensure some form of textual outcome, even if only in the form of guidelines, on large-scale REDD+ projects – an issue that resurfaces every year and is postponed year after year. The countries most interested in revenue from large-scale forestry projects clearly want to understand how to channel their potential, which in some cases was already committed to similar initiatives during the Kyoto period, under Article 6 with as little reputational risk as possible. At the same time, they do not wish to apply, as is becoming evident, all the rules and standards of the PACM, which many view as too stringent in terms of permanence requirements. This issue, too, remains unresolved for the time being.
Lastly, two tricky issues: one old and one new, albeit long-anticipated. The old issue concerns the term of office for members of the PACM Supervisory Body, the oversight body for the centralised mechanism. The same question arose at COP30 and can essentially be put in these terms: does it make sense to change the rules on appointments to the technical committee in the middle of its term, allowing current members (or some of them) to remain beyond the end of their term of office, in order to “preserve the institutional memory” of the mechanism during a phase of learning by doing? It goes without saying that the countries most interested in a regulatory change of this kind are those currently represented on the committee, particularly in view of the planned review of the entire Article 6 package in 2028. By then, it will be advantageous to have achieved minimum targets (to be “locked in” politically within the group) and to have loyal allies in the room during what will be a tough, no-holds-barred negotiation, given the many interests now vying for influence. Key figures from the former CDM Supervisory Body have recently spoken out publicly against such a regulatory change, which is, however, unlikely to find its way into the final COP decisions: it is simply too controversial.
And finally, the new issue, which we had actually been expecting. It is simple: both the technical support bodies for Article 6.2 (which manage the UN-side registries at an operational level) and the PACM are expected to be financially self-sustaining through contributions paid by participating countries, but the funds have not yet been received. In a context of an overall reduction in the UNFCCC Secretariat’s funds – and precisely in the absence of transactions on which to levy fees (even if these were special, start-up or one-off fees) – quite simply, the technical support bodies do not have the funds to carry out their work or to confirm contracts.
During the first week of the COP, some delegates attempted to propose special operational contributions to be paid by countries, distinct from the Share of Proceeds already provided for under the Paris Agreement and automatically allocated to the UN Adaptation Fund. But even the allocation of these funds has been the subject of a complex debate in recent days, with many countries calling for greater political influence over the Fund’s decisions, since they are, in effect, the ones providing the resources at the end of the day.
A new text is expected in these final hours that could serve as a minimum common ground between the various positions, but it is by no means certain that a decision will be reached between now and Saturday, 21 November. As anticipated, the most likely scenario at present appears to be a cool and, all things considered, non-committal “taking note” of the reports presented, thereby deferring all other issues to the next interim negotiations in June 2027. And then on to COP32.
Cover: photo by Kubilay Ciftci © UN Climate Change, via Flickr

